Judicial Determination of Punishment in Light of the Changing Status of Legal Persons in the Legal Systems of Afghanistan and Iran
Abstract
The judicial determination of punishment for legal persons in the legal systems of Afghanistan and Iran is a complex and multifaceted issue that, especially in the context of changes in the status of these entities, assumes new dimensions. Legal persons, as independent legal entities, bear responsibilities under the law and, in certain cases, may be subjected to punishments proportionate to their violations. This study analyzes the relationship between the changing status of legal persons and the imposition of punishments in the two legal systems of Afghanistan and Iran. Changes in the status of legal persons may include dissolution, bankruptcy, managerial restructuring, or transfer of ownership. Each of these changes can have significant implications for the legal responsibilities and punishments imposed on these entities. In the Iranian legal system, relevant laws and regulations provide specific frameworks for determining punishments; however, due to existing deficiencies, there is a need for review and reform. Similarly, the Afghan legal system faces comparable challenges, influenced by political developments and other contextual factors. This research adopts a comparative analytical method to examine the strengths and weaknesses of each system and offers recommendations for improving judicial and legislative practices in the area of sentencing legal persons. The findings of this study indicate that a lack of consistency and unified procedures in determining punishments can result in injustice and the infringement of stakeholders' rights. Ultimately, the author emphasizes the necessity of developing comprehensive and effective legal frameworks that can adequately address the impact of changes in the status of legal persons on judicial sentencing and safeguard the rights of both the public and individuals.
References
2. Samiei, Hossein (1994). Criminal Law, 4th Edition, Tehran: Matbooat Publishing Company.
3. Ardabili, Mohammad Ali (2014). General Criminal Law, Vol. 2, 3rd Edition, Tehran: Mizan Publishing.
4. Sharifi, Mohsen & Habibzadeh, Mohammad Jafar (Spring and Summer 2016). “Criteria for Determining Monetary Fines for Legal Persons in the Criminal Justice Systems of Iran, the United States, and the United Kingdom,” Journal of Criminal Law Studies, Vol. 7, No. 1.
5. Nikoumanzari, Amin & Shamloo, Bagher (Spring and Summer 2021). “Sanctions for Legal Persons with Emphasis on the Functions of Punishment in the Criminal Justice Systems of Iran, the United Kingdom, and the United States,” Journal of Criminal Law Studies, No. 23.
6. Janati Sadr, Hossein (2018). Determination of Penalties for Legal Persons in Iranian Criminal Law, Master’s Thesis, University of Tehran.
7. Pradel, Jean (2015). History of Criminal Thought, translated by Dr. Najafi Abrandabadi, 10th Edition, Tehran: SAMT Publishing.
8. Farajollahi, Reza (2009). Criminal Liability of Legal Persons in French Law, 1st Edition, Tehran: Mizan Publishing.
9. Islamic Penal Code of the Islamic Republic of Iran, enacted in 2013 [1392 in the Solar Hijri calendar].
10. Goldouzian, Iraj (2008). Essentials of General Criminal Law, 21st Edition, Tehran: Mizan Publishing.
11. Kohestani, Saber (2019). The Scope of Criminal Liability of Public Legal Persons, Master’s Thesis, University of Mazandaran.
12. Collective Authors (2019). Commentary on the Afghan Penal Code, Kabul: Asia Foundation Publications.
13. Mousavi Mojab, Seyed Darid & Rafizadeh, Ali (Spring 2015). “Sanctions for Crimes Committed by Legal Persons under the 2013 Islamic Penal Code,” Judicial Law Perspectives Quarterly, No. 69.
14. Sharifi, Mohsen; Habibzadeh, Mohammad Jafar; and Farajeeha, Mohammad (Spring and Summer 2014). “Assessment of Criminal Sanctions for Legal Persons (Analysis of Article 20 of the 2013 Islamic Penal Code),” Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, No. 3.
15. Salehi, Marzieh (2016). Criminal Liability of Legal Persons under the Computer Crimes Law, Master’s Thesis, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad.
16. Pourbafrani, Hassan & Seifi, Mahdieh (Spring and Summer 2015). “Typology of Punishments for Legal Persons,” Criminal Law Teachings, No. 9, Vol. 2.
17. Afghan Penal Code, enacted in 2016 [1395 in the Solar Hijri calendar.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Copyright for this article is retained by the author(s), with first publication rights granted to the journal. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
